Anti-corruption measures still lacking – GRECO

The new draft code of ethics for Malta’s members of parliament contains no provisions for sanctions and their effective enforcement in the case of violations, according to a follow-up report published on 31 May by the Group of States against Corruption (GRECO).

It is one of the examples used in the report by the Council of Europe’s anti-corruption body to underscore that, to date, only four of the Council of Europe’s nine recommendations have been adequately implemented.

The Council of Europe’s latest publication (an addendum to GRECO’s second compliance report) found that Malta continues to lag behind when it comes to fully implementing the nine recommendations that deal with “corruption prevention in respect of members of parliament, judges and prosecutors”.

In its recommendations for members of parliament, the report notes that although the Maltese government has adopted the Act on Standards in Public Life and a Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards has been appointed, the review of the code of ethics has not yet been completed, while the Act on Standards in Public Life does not provide sufficiently discouraging sanctions in the event of violations, neither does the revised code of ethics.

The Maltese authorities have argued that despite the lack of sanctions for infringements of ethical rules, the mere mention by the Standards Commissioner that an MP is in violation of these rules constitutes a “reputational damage” and is in itself a dissuasive effect.  The Council of Europe replied in no uncertain terms that sanctions were specifically indicated in the relevant recommendation and further stated that “it is not convinced that the “reputational damage” alone is equivalent to “effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions”.

The Council of Europe concluded that ensuring appropriate supervision and enforcement of rules on declaration of assets, interests and outside activities through effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions was still needed. Moreover, confidential counselling for MPs on ethical questions, conflicts of interest, and financial declarations still need to be established.

With regards to the Council of Europe’s recommendations for the judiciary, the report welcomed the fact that disciplinary proceedings, including dismissal of judges, is no longer within the competence of parliament and the report was satisfied with the measures taken to strengthen the system of judicial independence and accountability by making the Commission for the Administration of Justice in charge of judicial discipline procedures. Yet it also noted that no tangible steps have been taken to improve the transparency of such procedures in the judiciary.

It also found that the recommendations of an induction training programme for newly appointed judges still need to be implemented, covering judicial ethics, as does a regular in-service training programme, targeted guidance and counselling on corruption prevention and judicial ethics should be established for various professionals of courts.

The government has been invited to publish and translate the report and to submit to the Council of Europe further information on the five partially implemented recommendations by no later than 31 March 2022.

                           
                               
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
carlo
carlo
14 days ago

On August 16, 2020, Aldo Cutajar, the Maltese consul in Shanghai and brother of civil service head Mario Cutajar, was charged with money laundering and tax evasion. A police raid on his home yielded €500,000 in cash and hundreds of thousands in luxury items, including Rolex watches, two luxury Mercedes cars and other vehicles.

Aldo, and his wife, Isabel, had paid for the luxury vehicles in cash. In addition, they had a Dubai bank account holding over €300,000. They purchased a villa in Naxxar, a penthouse and garages in Swatar and a property in Tuscany. They also held €2 million in Satabank – read full TOM 30th May 2021 – READ: Who else wrecked Malta’s reputation? – Kevin Cassar
Any news regarding this fraudster and the artful corrupt dodger’s cousin robert falzon?
MAFIA MALTA will never hold them responsible – where is our new head of the police farce?

If only the hard working honest worker reads and understands what the corrupt muvument has done and is still doing to him and his family.

rule of the lawless.

mick
mick
14 days ago
Reply to  carlo

I’m afraid Carlo, that the Police Chief is just a clone of the Muscat commissioner as is the Prime Minister a clone of him. This is still Mafialand, their grip on the nation and structures is unshakeable, only the people can turn this round and there is a great reluctance to get out on the streets and pull this crock of shit down, but it’s the only way.

Related Stories

65 % think corruption in government is a big problem – survey
Two-thirds of Maltese people think that government corruption is
PA decides on Tuesday on Marsascala pool project planned in secret negotiations
The Environment and Planning Review Tribunal will decide on
Support investigative journalism that speaks truth to power.