An attack on the independence of the judiciary

ANALYSIS: 38 months since Daphne Caruana Galizia was killed, it is clear that the quest for reform, justice and accountability remains long, complex and uncertain.

 

A statement by the government on Tuesday attacked the judges conducting the public inquiry into the assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia for decreeing they will keep hearing evidence beyond the deadline arbitrarily set by the prime minister.

The statement is odd because it is unattributed: press statements are normally made in the name of Ministries, or the Office of the Prime Minister, or other government entities – yesterday’s statement was merely attributed to the ‘Government of Malta’.

It was a short statement. Yet in its 52 words, it is packed with cryptic threats: it accuses the judges of having appropriated the “power to extend the terms of the inquiry indefinitely”, and then asserts that the “Board would have to carry responsibility for its decision”.

The statement did not go into the rationale of the Board’s decree, nor did it make any cogent arguments on why the judges’ decision to keep hearing evidence is wrong.

In this sense, the statement is plainly intimidatory and it amounts to an attack on the independence of the judiciary.

It is the latest outburst in orchestrated attacks on the public inquiry by the former and present prime ministers. Robert Abela even revealed a few months ago that the two retired judges on the Board were being paid €4,000 monthly, insinuating that they had an interest in prolonging the inquiry to make more money.

The two retired judges – Michael Mallia and Joseph Said Pullicino – preempted these base, personal attacks by stating last Monday that they would be renouncing payment for the rest of the duration of the inquiry. This showed their interest lies in achieving the aims of the public inquiry, in the hope that the country achieves some kind of wider justice, reform and closure.

It is hugely telling that instead of being humbled by their altruism, the government reacted by lashing out at them.

This latest attack, even though it’s the most menacing yet, follows a pattern of attacks on the public inquiry by key members of the government and Labour’s partisan media. This is undermining the inquiry before it even completes its work, and perhaps setting the stage for eventually ignoring its recommendations.

The main complaint within Labour is that the inquiry has been politicised by the lawyers of Caruana Galizia’s family – Therese Comodini Cachia and Jason Azzopardi – and it has become a wide, partisan attack on Labour in government. Irrespective of the intentions of the two lawyers who double as Opposition MPs, the inquiry is helpful because it is revealing systematic rot and the inability of Ministers – even those who claim to have been at odds with what went on – to take a stand against wrongdoing.

It is also similarly revealing a network of enablers in lower levels of the pecking order.

Although this is neither new nor unique to Labour, it is a weakness in our governance, and handicap of our troubled democracy, that allowed a few people at the core of power to form a close relationship with big business interests and then go on to capture and weaken the institutions of democracy and rule of law.

And that contributed to the assassination of a journalist – the crime itself happened in that context, not in a vacuum. In fact, an argument can be made that the inquiry’s focus is not as wide as it ought to reveal more of the even broader context.

The only way to ensure that this does not happen again is to allow the full truth to come out and to carry out comprehensive reforms.

The reforms that have been carried to date, although laudable, have been fragmentary and insufficient. In fact, parts of the constitutional and legal reforms initiated last summer have been rendered impotent by loopholes – and the government has no intention of closing these loopholes.

The government has been rushing through legal amendments and reforms that are at best poorly designed and at worst in bad faith, acting under pressure to tick the boxes in the run-up to the decision by the Council of Europe’s Moneyval next spring on whether to ‘greylist’ Malta, the first EU country facing such censure.

The most recent move in this regard is the Bill on regulating the legal profession presented in parliament earlier this month – the Bill does nothing to raise standards and accountability among lawyers.

All of this shows that the quest for reform, justice and accountability remains long, complex and uncertain.

                           
                               
guest
5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paul Pullicino
Paul Pullicino
1 month ago

The Labour establishment has never understood or been motivated by a civic sense of duty. They will attack anyone who has it because it is in deep contrast to their total lack of it. Ask yourself why a prime minister creates fake ministries for incompetent backbenchers which increases the size of the Executive to that of three times of its remaining parliamentary group.

Last edited 1 month ago by Paul Pullicino
stefan
stefan
1 month ago

Friction between the MLP core group, Keith feels abandoned with his money frozen whilst J.P. and JM run around scot-free/ He stated” JM was aware of everything I did, nothing done behind his back” meaning all business deals, offshore companies, the frame up on Dr C. Cardona, and everything Yurgen was doing. If Keith is found guilty DCG s murder than JM is involved too.. This is what KS meant when he stated under oath that JM was aware and informed on everything keith Schembri did. “Qatt ma ghamilt xejn min wara dhar Joseph Muscat” I created you.

Joseph
Joseph
1 month ago

Ma jinbidlu qatt. Dik l’istampa li tigik fil-mohh tas 70 ma tista tmut u tisparixxi qatt. Dik tal-Mazza tfarrak pajjizna. Il-problema hija li ghal egoizmu, in-nies, il-pajjiz kollu tinsa min x’hiex tkun ghaddiet.

Henry s Pace
Henry s Pace
1 month ago

‘ attacks on the public inquiry by key members of the government and Labour’s partisan media. ‘
This confirms that there is a consistent build-up to discredit the judges

Henry s Pace
Henry s Pace
1 month ago

Malta is being led by a highly DIABOLICAL prime minister.

Related Stories

Multi-million euro illegal gambling activity remains unchecked in Malta
An ongoing investigation by The Shift has uncovered a