Transport Malta defies freedom of information order on cost of 5 new defective RHIBs

Transport Malta seems to have trouble providing financial information on five brand new Rigid Hull Inflatable Boats (RHIBs), bought in 2021 for its enforcement section, with some already declared unseaworthy.

The beleaguered transport regulator has repeatedly failed to observe time limits imposed in the Freedom of Information Act to provide the necessary information.

Following revelations on how the RHIBs, bought only two years ago, had to be beached after developing severe structural defects, The Shift last July asked Transport Malta to provide it with the cost of these RHIBs, the tender through which they were bought, and a list of payments made in the last two years on repairs on every RHIB.

Minister Aaron Farrugia’s Transport Malta has failed to reply despite repeated reminders, ignoring rigid time limits regulated by the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act.

The Shift was forced to use the FOI system as both the minister and his newly installed CEO, Jonathan Borg, repeatedly failed to reply to questions on the subject.

The latest scandal dates back to 2021 when Ian Borg was the minister responsible for Transport Malta. Five brand new RHIBs were bought from an agent in Rabat – Borg’s electoral district.

It is as yet unclear whether these boats, which cost over half a million euro, were purchased through a tender or a direct order.

Problems started as soon as they were put to sea, with Transport Malta employees complaining about how the seacrafts were not up to standard.

The Shift revealed how an expert report drawn up by a surveyor, after inspecting the five ‘new’ boats, found major problems. Structural damage was found on two of the boats that rendered them unusable.

“The extent of damage seen on ER1 (one of the RHIBs) is deemed to be major,” the surveyor concluded.

“It is strongly advised for ER1 to be placed out of service. The craft’s primary hull structure has been heavily compromised and is no longer deemed seaworthy,” the damning report found.

“Similar instances of damage are being noted on ER2 (another RHIB), the expert reported. Continued use of this unit will inevitably lead to the same degree of damages seen on ER1,” it was noted.

The surveyor wrote that ER2 would be used in a limited fashion and only in good weather.

Problems were also noted on all the other RHIBs.

The Shift understands that Transport Malta spent additional hundreds of thousands to try to fix the situation following the technical reports, with limited results.

It is unclear whether the reported damages to the new RHIBs were due to structural damages at the time of purchase or developed only after Transport Malta enforcement officers started using them.

So far, no legal measures have been taken by Transport Malta to protect its interest and public funds used for these RHIBs.

                           

Sign up to our newsletter

Stay in the know

Get special updates directly in your inbox
Don't worry we do not spam
                           
                               
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andy
Andy
4 months ago

Scandalous indeed but not the biggest maritime issue. A question to government and/or the AFM regarding damages and inherent faults in the overpriced patrol vessel P71 would also likely be ignored, too much to hide.

makjavel
makjavel
4 months ago

Ir was all in the T.O.M.
Boats ordered against a specification when delivered were found to be not to the specification.
Instead of being returned and the supplier not paid , being a friend, was asked to modify them.
This obviously resulted in the warranty provided by the Original Manufacture void and to make it worse , the modifications were not accepted by the Certification Engineer.
Another corrupt deal , where when corruption money changes hands it is impossible to reverse the deal. Ian Borg and friends messed this up , but according to Robert Abela , it government possibly to help friends get money from the government.

Dunalf@yahoo.com
Dunalf@yahoo.com
4 months ago

Another ha,,,,,,,,, .we have to pay whilst others get commissions ?

Mark Debono
Mark Debono
4 months ago

I think it is obvious who supplied the rhibs and of course he is well connected and probably protected as well?

Colin
Colin
4 months ago

Bought and not fit for purpose. Surely a refund is due ?

Related Stories

PBS Chair Mark Sammut blocks information on newsroom appointments
PBS has refused to make public information on a
€130,000 spent on marketing Stabbiltà scheme, government shy on details
The government has spent some €130,000 to promote the

Our Awards and Media Partners

Award logo Award logo Award logo