Opinion: Integrity counts

In March 2023, the court declared the Vitals hospital concession fraudulent, but President George Vella simply brushed off questions on whether he felt any responsibility.

 “We are waiting for objective reports on facts and figures, and then we speak after that”, he barked in default aggressive hostility.

We’re now “after that” as the court of appeal has issued its definitive judgement. “Senior officials” in Labour’s government, of which Vella was one, colluded with Vitals to draw up a fake contract (simulat) intended “to funnel money out of state coffers and into the pockets of Vitals”.

The sentence is scathing of the Labour Party’s collusion to the detriment of the national interest and the millions of euros it cost the country.

Vella has all the objective reports he needs: Detailed NAO reports bursting with facts and figures. Even Steward published all the audited management accounts since 2015 for him to scrutinise at leisure.

And now he has a 99-page sentence brimming with the most disgusting facts about Labour’s betrayal of the nation. His government defrauded the country and sought the interests of Vitals instead of the national interest. But Vella maintains his complicit silence.

In March, he was asked whether he had ever objected to privatising the three hospitals.  He replied, “Studies and preparations were made for the deals at the time”. 

What studies?  No studies were performed, no medical professionals were consulted, and the medical association was not even informed when Labour drew up its top-secret Memorandum of Understanding in October 2014 with a gang of scammers, later to become Vitals.

What preparations? The only preparation Labour made was opening up secret offshore companies in top-secret financial jurisdictions. And what did Vella do?  He defended Konrad Mizzi in parliament and shielded his party and its rotten leaders.

Vella is a doctor- he knew that Ram Tumuluri and his secret collaborators had never run a clinic, let alone a hospital. His medical colleagues warned him that this was a scam from the very start.

Daphne Caruana Galizia exposed Tumuluri’s shady past and his utter unfitness for the role he was taking on. Vella knew this, yet he vociferously defended Labour’s fraud at the expense of the people’s health, which he took an oath to preserve.

“If a deal goes wrong, one can’t say it was premeditated”, Vella declared. Is the man just dumb or deviously dishonest?

Well, the court sentence has completely demolished Vella’s defence of his crooked friends. “The intention behind the concession wasn’t improvement in medical services but simply to serve as a means to funnel money from state coffers into the pockets of Vitals”, leaving us with no doubt that everything was pre-meditated.

“Even the Memorandum of Understanding of 10 October 2014, from the very start, did not reflect the intended project but served only as an instrument for Vitals to gain the necessary information from the government to prepare its proposal in readiness for the request for proposals of 27 March 2015”, the sentence reads.

When “the deal goes wrong”, our political leaders should be there to protect our interests, but they didn’t. “Nothing was done about any part of the project as evidenced by the list of unachieved milestones”. 

The court couldn’t have been more explicit: “Those who had the duty to protect the national interest gave one extension after another to conceal the fact that the agreement was just a facade and not the real deal and continued to pay millions of euros to Vitals/Steward even though they were not meeting their obligations”.

Vella was one of those with the duty to protect the national interest, but he failed to do so, and instead, he voted to protect Konrad Mizzi and in cabinet to provide extensions to Vitals. He is as complicit and responsible for the biggest fraud in Malta’s history as the rest of his cabinet colleagues.

His votes helped Joseph Muscat “give the impression that everything was going well” when it was clear that “the project was undeliverable”. That contract was “the fruit of simulation and collusion”, and George Vella was part of it.

No wonder he refuses to condemn it or brushes off questions about his responsibility.

If our president had the slightest grain of integrity in his body, he would step down.  He is politically responsible for the “simulation and collusion” as he formed part of that cabinet that engineered the theft of hundreds of millions of euros from the people. 

He is to blame for the dilapidated state of St Luke’s, the failure to build a new Gozo hospital, the appalling state in which patients are cared for in a hospital canteen, the medical school library and an underground corridor. He has no place occupying any seat of office, least of all the office of president.

In several corrupt countries, such as Pakistan, Mali, Nigeria, Liberia and South Africa, a reality show called “Integrity Idol” has gained immense popularity.  Over 10 million people have watched it, and over 400,000 have voted. 

In the show, honest public officials compete for glory and fame. “Integrity Idol” honours those who speak up against corruption, put themselves at risk to protect their nation, and speak out against the criminality of senior politicians.

The show delivers a punch in the face to crooked politicians and their cronies. Maybe it’s time to bring the show to Malta. If it’s brought here, Vella will not be on it.

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Robert Agius
Robert Agius
1 month ago

It is about time someone calls out the fake President we have. Just another party functionary who has the integrity of a stone – remember the “Alla jhares nidhlu fl-Ewropa” anyone? Thank you Dr Cassar for this, and your other well researched pieces.

He is now being repaid for dishonouring his oaths of parliament, minister and president by spending our hard earned money on first class travel all across the globe while Nero fiddles from the roof.

George Vella was an active member of the most corrupt cabinet in our history, that was held responsible for Daphne’s death – NEVER forget that. And stop fucking shaking hands and smiling when you meet him. Give him a piece of your mind!

It is also time to attack the civil servants, who endorsed every decision to make it effective – corrupt as they were.

Last edited 1 month ago by Robert Agius
Raymond Borg
1 month ago
Reply to  Robert Agius

Exellently said

Godfrey Leone Ganado
Godfrey Leone Ganado
1 month ago

George Vella has family members who have been making hay while the sun shines, and is therefore gagged.
George Vella when welcoming the MLP honourables, including Joseph Muscat, at the President’s palace in San Anton, just after being crowned as President, had started his welcome speech by saying that he had no words with which to thank them for an unexpected appointment as President.
He has however been on payback mode since then.
George Vella – once again I have to tell you “SHAME ON YOU” and to highlight once again that as a member of the cabinet you were individually and collectively responsible for allowing this massive government fraud to happen, and in your case even more being in the medical profession and a family doctor surely listening to the complaints of your patients about the hospitals situation.
You did’nt even raise an eyebrow unless you hid it under your bushy ones.

Francis Said
Francis Said
1 month ago

Next Inquiry AUM. Another huge white elephant.

1 month ago

gv was and still is one of the corrupt muvument’s trolls. he had his iced bun so why worry.

1 month ago

Question: Why do politicians take an oath of office on their appointment?
Answer: Because that oath says ‘You swear to ensure that the interests of those near you and of yourself are adequately protected and enhanced; that you will ride roughshod over any moral, social and legal inhibitions tending to limit your ability to abuse your position; that notwithstanding protests, criticism and negative publicity, you will never resign your position; that you will lie through your teeth to protect yourself and your colleagues … so help me (whoever you believe in, its not important anyway because we all know that the priority is to become rich and to retain power)

Lawrence Mifsud
Lawrence Mifsud
29 days ago
Reply to  Hopeless

Adding “hekk Alla jghinni”

carmelo borg
1 month ago

WELL SAİD. Vella ghandu idejh İMCAPSİN BİL HMİEG (ghalkemm mhux hu dirett) kien komplici meta ivvota ghal din il korruzjoni kolla. Mela meta gew ghal ligi ta l abort (naqbel mieghu) qal li kien lest li jirrizenja imissu jaghmel l istess issa.
Darba fi speech li kien qed jaghmel qal li qabda GANG li hatfu kollox.
İssa se jghid wara din is sentenza li l imhalfin qalu li il gvern (inkluz hu bhala membru tal kabinet ta dak iz zmien) kienu in kolluzjoni mal QERQ U SERQ TA DİN İL BRAVURA CONSESSİON?????
Ohrog ta ragel u irrizenja jew ghal inqas itlob SKUZA Lİ POPLU MALTİ

Jools Seizure
Jools Seizure
1 month ago

There can be plenty of discussion about who was our best president but never about who was our worst … by the proberbial country mile.

1 month ago

Not my President………

Edward Mallia
Edward Mallia
1 month ago

Vella is a doctor- he knew that Ram Tumuluri and his secret collaborators had never run a clinic, let alone a hospital. 

A dagger thrust to the heart for President George Vella. There is really no way he can wriggle out of that clear proof that he was prepared to turn a blind eye to a clear swindle of public money. But I suggest that Kevin Cassar’s ”dagger” has wider implications. There was another person who was actually part of the Vitals- Ram Tumuluri crowd: Armin Ernst was a doctor in a senior position with Steward — before anyone here had heard of Steward, a firm which did have major experience in providing health care. Yet Ernst chose to change employers, moving to Vitals before Vitals had even secured the Malta contract. That and his subsequent behavior suggests strongly that Steward were convinced from the start that Vitals was doomed to fail. The presence of Ernst does not seem to have exerted much brake in the downhill rush. It did provide Steward, however, with good timing when to ride to the rescue and when that ”rescue” was complete, a smooth return of Armin Ernst to the Steward fold.

Related Stories

Opinjoni: żball oħxon ta’ Joseph Muscat
This opinion was originally written in English. This below
Opinion: Joseph Muscat’s blunder
This opinion piece is available in Maltese. “Today, for

Our Awards and Media Partners

Award logo Award logo Award logo