Labour’s new poor – Kevin Cassar

The average apartment in Malta costs €300,000. That’s the same as Holland.  But the average salary in Malta in 2022 was €21,156 but in Holland it is €51,500. It’s more than twice as hard to afford a roof over your head here – which is why so many young people simply cannot.

Between 2013 and 2022 house prices doubled.  The median young couple can just about afford a 115-square-metre apartment on a 35-year loan.  The average single person simply cannot afford a property in Labour’s Malta. And if they rent, it costs them 42% more than it did in 2013 when Labour came to power.

The average gross salary in 2013 was €16,022 and it is now €21,156. The sad reality is that despite Labour’s bluff of “the best of times” (L-Aqwa zmien), ironically reminiscent of Dickens’ Tale of Two Cities, those young people’s salaries have only increased by 32% but the price of property has increased by 100%

Labour’s policies have driven property prices to crisis levels, a debt-ridden crisis. A 2019 Financial Times report concluded that Malta’s golden visa programme contributed to soaring property prices. Malta’s low effective tax rate of 5%, the lowest in Europe, attracted many foreign companies but also significantly increased the population.  During Labour’s decade in power, the proportion of non-Maltese residents increased from 4.9% to 22.2%.  There are 115,449 non-Maltese residing in Malta – that’s one-fifth of the population. They contribute significantly to the economy but they’re also part of the reason that Malta’s young people are being priced out of the property market and why rental prices have sky-rocketed.

In a study of 200 cities, 90% were deemed unaffordable because the average home cost more than three times the average income.  In Malta, it costs more than 13 times the average income.

Those who buy their home will be burdened with a staggering monthly loan repayment. Those who cannot really afford to spend more than half their income on rent. That means less money for food, bills and other essentials.

Malta’s generous energy subsidies are what’s keeping many afloat. As the IMF pushes Malta to end those subsidies, many face the real prospect of having their homes repossessed.

Labour will resist pressures to cut subsidies.  It knows many are struggling and cutting that lifeline would tip them over the edge.  At a time of high inflation and rising mortgage costs, many would not be able to buffer that blow and Labour knows Robert Abela’s high approval ratings would quickly evaporate if the economic tide turns.

So Labour will continue to borrow to buy itself more time in power.  But rising interest rates have made government borrowing more costly. As government revenue falls, Labour will be constrained to cut spending.

Those cuts won’t come through rationing of political appointments, terminating double CEO salaries, cutting the FMS CEO’s inflated wage, or by cutting direct contracts for Labour’s funders.  Those cuts will come from public services.  Labour restricts funding, even for life-saving treatment, while it continues to lavish obscene and undeserved salaries and perks on total incompetents.

The only reason housing is not yet in crisis is that adult children continue to live with their parents.  The average age at which a Maltese adult leaves home is 29. In Sweden, it’s 19 and in Finland it’s 21.

The real prospect of homelessness is deferred through the generosity of parents who allow adult children, and their families, to share their property. That creates its own problems – overcrowding, familial conflicts, social issues such as reduced birth rates, delayed pregnancies, restricted family size, and increasing pressure on elderly parents to sell up and downsize.

Many young adults can only afford a deposit on a property because their own parents sacrificed theirs.

The need for social housing is bound to increase. Thousands are still waiting, years later, for social accommodation. As property prices become increasingly unaffordable, and as interest rates continue to rise, more young people will be priced out of the market. Marriage breakdowns and divorces will only make that problem worse.

But it’s not just the young that are affected.  The over-50s have seen the most significant increase in the proportion of low wages. At that age, no bank will extend a loan.  The combination of increasing property prices and the rising cost of living is creating the perfect storm – a slow strangulation of our society.

What is disturbingly odd is that the category of people most negatively affected by Labour’s policies is some of its staunchest supporters. Labour enjoys its highest ratings among the least educated, who are the lowest earners. They can only watch as the very rich purchase and rent property in their hometowns and villages, squeezing them out. While their parents could easily afford their own property, they can only dream of being able to do the same.

In 2013, the at-risk-of-poverty rate in Malta stood at 15.7%.  In 2021 it was at 20.3%.  That’s a staggering 105,471 people in Malta at risk of poverty under Labour.  In 2013 only 66,785 people in Malta were at risk of poverty.

Labour has managed to almost double that number.

Portugal has just scrapped its ‘golden visas’ to “fight against price speculation in real estate”. Ireland has done the same. So did Cyprus.

Portugal’s decision was driven by angst over a surge in house prices that left local residents struggling to find adequate accommodation. It is part of a package of measures designed to combat the housing crisis.

The Costa government has a plan to address housing affordability problems.  Abela’s government doesn’t, ignoring the plight of its citizens.

Labour is producing a generation of dependents who simply cannot cut themselves free of their umbilical cord. Those dependents are resentful of their parents’ luck. They had a simpler life but they also had everything they needed, including roofs over their heads.

Their offspring are compelled to live with their parents, possibly hoping they’ll die soon so they can finally have a place of their own.

This is Labour’s legacy: a new army of poor and homeless citizens.

Sign up to our newsletter

Stay in the know

Get special updates directly in your inbox
Don't worry we do not spam
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

14 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gahan
Gahan
1 year ago

Are you sure the average gross salary is 21,000 ? Would say less!

Steve Borg
Steve Borg
1 year ago
Reply to  Gahan

I think that many have far less, more around the 15K mark!

carlos
carlos
1 year ago

This is Labour’s legacy: a new army of poor and homeless citizens.

BUT millions for our corrupt ministers and people of trust who buy villas away from Mafiamalta – away from it all -whilst letting the problems be faced the gahan malti mostly the low class workers who were and still are being screwed up on this rock. Mafiamalta the place for lazy, corrupt, and fraudsters. The oligarchs don’t bother as they will fly out as soon as problems crop up. SHAME.

raymond
raymond
1 year ago

An incredibly realistic snapshot of the dire situation in Malta. But still the Gahan applauds this mafia government.

A. Fan
A. Fan
1 year ago

We can also thank Draghi, La Garde and the rest of the geniuses at the ECB who kept depressing interest rates with their purchase of government (and even corporate) debt securities for more than a decade. ‘Free money’ led to massive speculation in financial and fixed assets, including homes. It’s their brilliance that brought us rampant inflation (which, in their arrogance, they thought they could fine tune to their 2% target). Not that the Fed or BOJ have been any smarter…

viv
viv
1 year ago
Reply to  A. Fan

Well that lets the gov/mafia off the hook!
I presume that since the few at the top were mightily busy filling their boots, getting caught and now tying the country up in knots with their dense and incessant covering-ups while they should have been actually governing, that blame is to lie anywhere but with them?
There will be months and endless months of desperate and cringe-inducing propaganda, made up stats and deflections ahead.
Why make it worse?

saviour mamo
saviour mamo
1 year ago

To make things worse the government of Robert Abela is making this country a debt ridden state. He is borrowing money at every opportunity and as a consequence ,he has to pay more money on interest payments, instead of spending money on security services, education and health.

Joseph
Joseph
1 year ago

Excellent analysis!

The cycle of greed has turned full circle.

wenzu
wenzu
1 year ago

Bobby is OK with HIS properties and boat- if the stupid gahan still look up to this two face, more fool them.

Godfrey Leone Ganado
Godfrey Leone Ganado
1 year ago

When a certain Godfrey Leone Ganado stated unequivocally that before Malta gets to this state of poverty and more homeless and beggars in the streets, he was flogged by every Labour Gahan, called names and had his photo splashed over the scum Labour media with his statement. This is still done from time to time, but they have not yet realised that his approach was and still is to give them the middle finger and keep happily moving on.
The anything but fit and proper, scum Silvio Schembri even showed his stupidity in not understanding the logical message he was conveying and accused the PN representatives in the debate on the media that they were not censuring him with his close attachment to the PN.
That was ME, and today I laugh when I am seeing even worse than I thought, and I point my fingers at our irresponsible and crooked government members and their rent seekers for leading us all to the edge of a cliff, and all I say is “enjoy it Gahans”, while the middle fingers of your idols will remain pointed.

Nikola
Nikola
1 year ago

It is clear that you somehow make it a way to speak on behalf of the PN, after all you are from Repubblika AKA a branch of the PN party

Joseph Grech
Joseph Grech
1 year ago
Reply to  Nikola

Nikola, whoever you are, you’re such an arsehole❗

Thomas
Thomas
1 year ago

This all reads with the hindsight in it in regards to the comparison with the situation of today as it was either rather part and parcel of Joseph Muscat’s great economy plan, or he simply calculated it as the unavoidable risk and if it’s not that, then he must have simply ignored such financial upheavals.

Either way, the concept, whatever it really was, has only paid off for himself and his chums. But when one takes it as the real concept of the PL to have a means to bind people to vote for them in the long run, this articles tells it all. There is the big fear among the PLers, certainly also nourished by the older generations who lived through the PN eras, that once the PN would get into power again, it would be as worse as they say it was before the Mintoff era, and also the Fenech Adami era. There is a certan fearmongering among themselves which holds them back from facing the truth, even when confronted with it every day.

The MLP, and so the Mintoffians of old and young, always boasted with the way Mintoff dealt with the increase in rents and the housing problem in enabling average wages earners to afford their own home by simply putting a stop to it and freezing the rent prices. That was in the 1970s. But the principle of that era has been sacrificed by Muscat for the big money coming in and also what some other commenters to this article have said.

makjavel
makjavel
1 year ago

But Robert Abela gives out cake for New Year. and the hungry majority claps.
Give them cake , must have been hammered into Abela’s brain. Big junks to his friends bits to the his hungry voters.

Related Stories

Opinion: The developers’ friend at the Planning Authority
Martin Camilleri is a central figure at the Planning
Opinion: The deal with the devil
Labour promised us meritocracy.  Instead, Robert Abela gave the

Our Awards and Media Partners

Award logo Award logo Award logo