Sliding relentlessly to autocracy

Robert Abela’s new cabinet was sworn in.  Since then, the mobile phone numbers of all ministries’ spokespersons have been withheld. Communication aides are meant to aid communication.  Not for Robert Abela.

Their role is now to make it even more arduous for journalists to access government and to obtain any information from the executive branch. Their main objective is to make it impossible for the public to find out anything about its own government except that which government wants known.

The IGM, the journalists’ representative body, raised concerns about the lack of access to government with the OPM’s head of communication, Edward Montebello, who was previously ONE’s head of news.  His objective is hardly transparency. What is ingrained into him is secrecy, propaganda and manipulation of the truth.

Montebello refined those skills through years of working at Labour’s propaganda machine. Now he’s wielding those skills as OPM Head of communication to distort the narrative.

After the IGM meeting of 31 May, Montebello promised to look into the matter. Unsurprisingly, he hasn’t. He hasn’t even bothered to answer repeated questions on the issue. And nobody can call him because his mobile number is withheld.

Journalists are unable to perform their duties without appropriate access to government. The insurmountable difficulties they face in trying to get that access was highlighted in a 2020 LIBE report.  The situation is not only NOT getting better; it’s getting worse.

The report noted that journalists operate in a culture of intimidation and threats. Journalists “stressed the general climate of hate, intimidation and constant pressure in which they have to work” at meetings with the LIBE committee. They complained that “they can hardly access government”.

The Caruana Galizia inquiry recommended constitutional amendments to make freedom of expression and free journalism a pillar of a democratic society. It also recommended constitutional amendments on the right to receive information from the state and public administration and the obligation to provide such information. It recommended revision of the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act.

Even before Robert Abela’s latest assault on journalists, the World Press Freedom Index ranked Malta as the 3rd worst EU member state. The LIBE report indicated that “the ruling party wields a strong influence over the public broadcaster and uses public advertising to exert pressure on private media”.

It noted that “access to information, foreseen by the FOI Act, is often violated by public authorities, as requests are rejected, not answered or only partially answered, or replies are delayed”.

The OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media, Teresa Ribeiro, presented a legal analysis of two Maltese draft laws on the media.  She recommended, “to include the right to seek information as a basic component of the right to freedom of expression and freedom of information in the relevant amendments to the Constitution”.

Of course, that’s not going to happen. Not when the party leader and prime minister is Robert Abela, whose disdain and contempt for the independent media was made perfectly clear from the start.

For him, journalism is not an essential pillar of democracy but an enemy that needs to be controlled. Even as he launched his campaign to become party leader in late 2019, Abela didn’t even bother to invite the media. He failed to give any interviews despite aspiring to become prime minister.

He asserted that “I am not running from the media” despite refusing to accept to be interviewed by the independent media. “I welcome scrutiny from the media, but I want to maintain an appropriate distance”, he insisted.  But when he was asked about the more than €500,000 in direct orders he received, he went on the attack.

He cautioned the press, saying, “you should be more neutral”. His insolent reply was, “I paid back every cent I ever received from government through hard work and results”.  Presumably, those results included the €45,000 profit he made off the deal with alleged kidnapper Christian Borg. Or the rock bottom priced Zejtun property he acquired five days after the Planning Authority sanctioned all illegalities.

Abela refused to answer questions sent to him by the press. Repeatedly, he simply ignored the media’s questions. “I am being very careful in my engagement with the independent media,” he added.  He emphasised that he was intentionally keeping his distance to be ‘free to make decisions’.  What those decisions were are becoming increasingly apparent and increasingly disturbing.

His autocratic treatment of the free press hasn’t changed. On the eve of the last elections, he left a crowd of journalists waiting for hours, only to make a dash for the side door to give them the slip. The journalists had been invited by the OPM to a company launch.

They hadn’t been told they couldn’t ask questions.  When they objected, OPM personnel claimed that questions were not permitted since the company wasn’t allowing political questions on their property – a problem easily solved by stepping outside.  But by then, Abela was gone.

Journalists had been pursuing Abela for an interview for two years and two months. Abela refused a feature on a day in his life on the campaign trail. He refused a debate with the Leader of the Opposition. All efforts were turned down, prompting The Times of Malta to conduct a fake interview with an empty seat instead of the prime minister.

These are the tactics of spin dictators and autocrats. “Suppressing the free press is how dictators get started,” the late American senator John McCain had said, “we need a free press; we must have it. It’s vital”.

He noted that preserving democracy requires a free, often adversarial press:  “Without it, we lose too much of our liberties”. “Efforts on the part of a leader to undermine and manipulate the press are very dangerous,” McCain had warned. That is what Abela is up to.

Abela has been consistently stripping away at institutions protecting our democracy. We know where that leads.

                           
                               
guest
11 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
A. Fan
A. Fan
9 days ago

The Maltese must have voted for EU-lite a couple of decades back. The version where you exploit all the benefits of membership but assume none of the obligations that come with it. Seems that Hungary’s about to discover there’s no such option, and others will likely follow.

Out of Curiosity
Out of Curiosity
9 days ago

Robert Abela hijacked the LP, most of his inexperienced cabinet members and state institutions. To a certain extent he continues to manipulate the opinion of those who find it difficult to understand the complexities of political systems, the importance of good governance and creation of adequate wealth which would lead to abundant and fair distribution of same wealth. Unfortunately a big chunck of the Maltese who voted for the LP in the last general election have been blinded with pittance. Do you remember the distribution of cheques? An insult to those who treasure dignity. Sign of the times!

Francis Said
Francis Said
8 days ago

Greed has become a norm. Money is the new god.

adriang
adriang
9 days ago

Perhaps it is time to involve, more fully, news companies such as Reuters, BBC, Sky and others, so that maybe they can make Labour answer for their lack of governance -through international pressure.

Francis Said
Francis Said
8 days ago
Reply to  adriang

A possible but unlikely solution. Unfortunately our politicians in power are only interested in vote buying.

Joseph
Joseph
2 days ago
Reply to  Francis Said

And that’s what happened. They stole the election with Guda’s money. Almost a 100 k non voters were on sale. Imbaghad imorru jghollu il-qaddisin u l-vizxju tal-quddies. Wiehed ghaddieli kumment fuq din il-kwitjoni tax xiri tal-voti. Irid ikollok Kapacita. Jigifieri tal-lejber kapaci ferm jisirqu l’elezjoni. Ghann biex niftahru. Pajjiz tas-suwed u bojod.

Francis Said
Francis Said
8 days ago

Again a true reflection of the worsening state of our Country’s democracy, principles and values.
I state this with sadness as we all deserve better.

joe tedesco
joe tedesco
8 days ago

SLIDING CONTINUOUSLY TO DICTATORSHIP,
MINTOFFIAN STYLE.
NEVER,EVER,TRUST THE PL GOVERNMENT.

Janet Wojtkow
Janet Wojtkow
3 days ago

Unfortunately Malta is so tiny on the world stage, it doesn’t matter what they do although it should!

Chris
Chris
3 hours ago

I voted with a 51% heart to join the EU and only because it may discipline our politicians. It did only to a point that they had to observe other rules of the game.

Now the EU is working to organize a whole 28 state organization to strip away other minorities rights. It is a structure for total control. It not only favours certain businesses but ironically destroying our economy and freedoms.

A great example is when the idiotic/controlled EU puppets had the great idea to sanction Russian goods, especially gas. Hungary did not fall for it. EU Politicians now force higher prices to their local people. They do not care neither about being green at all, by reopening coal supplies to burn fuels for the previous coal generating electricity generators. The Russians now are getting more funds as prices are higher. A total boomerang effect. Do these EU commissioners care?

So now am opting for MALT-EXIT and to get out of the UN and WHO as the solution for our freedoms. The medical mafia at the WHO is running the doctor spin to vaccinate the world, with false scientific tests and reports to the great consternation of everyone who is a freedom lover.

Ask any questions or email authorities about the covid situation. They do not give you an answer, because it would expose them. This is why my friends and I are taking Charmaine Gauci to court, because the rule of law is not existant in this country and getting worse.

Using the “Freedom of information” llaw venue may work sometimes, but they can still hide behind other organizations to avoid getting embarrassed by the truth. This is why the media is supposed to be the pillar of democracy.

Chris
Chris
19 minutes ago

Thanks for Robert Abela for spitting it out:- “I am being very careful in my engagement with the independent media,”. Truth is his downfall as all free media wants to know the full unencumerbed truth, without interference, favour or having any side agreements with thier paid cronies.

It is the real independent media that is speaking the truth, not the paid whores of the mass media editors and thier journalists.

Related Stories

Embracing tyrants – Kevin Cassar
“Will they call von der Leyen corrupt?  Will they
Michael Zammit Tabona, anti-communist – Ranier Fsadni
We should all thank God that this country has

Our Awards and Media Partners

Award logo Award logo Award logo Award logo